A simple Answer TO yOUr Question
Which is better to sell my car to: CarMax, Carvana, or a local dealer?
Each option has different trade-offs. CarMax offers in-person appraisals with same-day payment and a 7-day price hold, which gives you time to shop the offer around. Carvana provides instant online offers and free pickup, but offers are sometimes lower than in-person competitors and can change at inspection. Local dealers often have more flexibility to negotiate and may offer above-market prices on vehicles they specifically need for their inventory. The best approach is to get quotes from all three (plus NADA and KBB as reference points) and let the competition work in your favor. Taking 30-60 minutes to collect multiple quotes frequently yields $500-$2,000 more for the same vehicle.
📥 FREE DOWNLOAD
The Smart Buyer's Guide to Leasing vs. Buying in 2026
Discover:
✓ When to lease vs. buy
✓ Hidden fees to watch for
✓ Tax benefits for business owners
✓ Current manufacturer incentives
Smart move!
Download the guide below, plus we've sent a copy to your inbox.
Affordable Cars Available Now
Value Tracking
No credit impact, view Get personalized insights on your car’s value, so you can time your next car with the most savings.real payments while shopping.
Insurance Coverage
Effortless to buy and personalized to you, with coverage deals with Vantage.
600+ Testimonials
What Our Customers Say
People come for the number. They stay for how easy we make it.
Lisa Salzberg
Lauren Nissenblatt
David Goldstein and his team are great. He was always available and responsive whenever I voiced a concern. He was quick to answer questions, which was extremely helpful it making decisions as I did not need to wait long to connect with him. I highly recommend connecting with David the next time you are looking for a vehicle!
David Goldstein and his team are great. He was always available and responsive whenever I voiced a concern. He was quick to answer questions, which was extremely helpful it making decisions as I did not need to wait long to connect with him. I highly recommend connecting with David the next time you are looking for a vehicle!
Joseph Bestreich
Fantastic to work with. Everyone on the team was great. They personally worked with us on pricing and model requests. Can’t recommend Vantage enough.
Fantastic to work with. Everyone on the team was great. They personally worked with us on pricing and model requests. Can’t recommend Vantage enough.
Ken Hurd
Stacy Sackett
It was a “fun” way to make a car purchase. Mark V. and the whole team were responsive, informative, and very friendly! Can’t wait to purchase the next one!! (😬🤪) Thank you!! Ulla & Bill
It was a “fun” way to make a car purchase. Mark V. and the whole team were responsive, informative, and very friendly! Can’t wait to purchase the next one!! (😬🤪) Thank you!! Ulla & Bill
W Shuler
Our experience with Vantage was extraordinary. Unexpectedly we found ourselves in a panic when our car just stopped and it was clear to us that we needed a new car! Our son recommended Mark Viegas and from start to finish, each step was seamless. Every person we encountered was professional , knowledgeable and excellent at their job. We were able to sell our original car and purchase a new car without any stress. We highly recommend Vantage Auto Group, Many Thanks for making this experience such a positive one Brad was also a pleasure to work with making sure the delivery was seamless
Our experience with Vantage was extraordinary. Unexpectedly we found ourselves in a panic when our car just stopped and it was clear to us that we needed a new car! Our son recommended Mark Viegas and from start to finish, each step was seamless. Every person we encountered was professional , knowledgeable and excellent at their job. We were able to sell our original car and purchase a new car without any stress. We highly recommend Vantage Auto Group, Many Thanks for making this experience such a positive one Brad was also a pleasure to work with making sure the delivery was seamless
Maureen Dorney
David Alesso made the impossible happen! My family grew & my SUV got very small FAST but I still had a year left on my lease. This was my 2nd time using Vantage Auto Group & David worked a miracle! Yet again, everything was very seamless & easy & my Telluride was delivered right to my door!
David Alesso made the impossible happen! My family grew & my SUV got very small FAST but I still had a year left on my lease. This was my 2nd time using Vantage Auto Group & David worked a miracle! Yet again, everything was very seamless & easy & my Telluride was delivered right to my door!
Jennifer Silver
Fantastic experience with Dave as always.
Fantastic experience with Dave as always.
Fil Mendes