Step 1: Know What Your Car Is Worth Before Anyone Else Does
Before you talk to a single buyer, spend 10 minutes on valuation. Pull your car's estimated range on Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds. These give you a ballpark, not a final price, but they tell you what category your car falls into and what a reasonable offer looks like. Walk into any buyer conversation already knowing what the range is, so you can evaluate their offer clearly instead of reacting to a number cold.
Note your car's actual condition honestly: mileage, any known mechanical issues, cosmetic damage, accident history on the Carfax, and how many previous owners. These factors will come up in every buyer's assessment. Knowing them in advance lets you price accurately and avoid surprises at inspection.
Step 2: Gather Your Documents First
The fastest sales are the ones where all the paperwork is ready before you start. Here is what you need:
- Title (certificate of title): Required for almost every buyer. If you have lost it, apply for a duplicate through the NJ MVC before you start the sale process.
- Loan payoff information: If you still owe money, contact your lender for the exact payoff amount and their process for receiving funds from a sale.
- Service records: Not always required, but they support your asking price with private buyers and can reduce the chance of an offer adjustment at inspection.
- Two valid forms of ID.
- Bill of sale template: A simple document recording the sale date, price, VIN, and both parties' information. Templates are available online.
In New Jersey, you will also want to submit Form OS/SS-7 (Seller's Report of Sale) to the MVC after the transaction is complete. This officially records that you are no longer the owner, which protects you from liability for what happens with the car afterward. For a full breakdown of what each document does and what to do if something is missing, see our complete guide on what paperwork you need to sell your car in NJ.
Step 3: Get Multiple Offers, Not Just One
This is where most sellers either follow through or leave money behind. Getting one offer is not market research; it is accepting one buyer's opening position. Getting two or three offers from different types of buyers is how you find out what the market will actually pay.
Target at least three different buyer types: an online platform (Carvana, CarMax, or similar), a dealership that sells your make, and a broker service. The total time is under an hour and the spread between offers frequently runs into the hundreds or thousands of dollars for the same car.
To get competing offers from multiple buyers at once without coordinating with each one separately, start your trade with Vantage. We contact buyers in our network on your behalf and bring you the results to compare.
Step 4: Compare the Offers and Decide
Once you have offers in hand, you are making a real decision instead of guessing. Compare them on the same terms: same vehicle description, same mileage, same condition. Look at the total you will receive, not just the headline number. An online buyer's offer may come with a payoff timeline that costs you extra days. A dealer's offer may include fees. Factor everything in before deciding.
Also consider what the process looks like for each option: how long will it take, what do you have to do, and what happens if something goes wrong. The highest offer is not always the right choice if the process creates significant risk or inconvenience.
Step 5: Complete the Sale and Protect Yourself
Whichever method you choose, a few steps protect you after the keys change hands:
- Get confirmation of the title transfer in writing and keep a copy.
- File Form OS/SS-7 with the NJ MVC to record the sale officially.
- Do not cancel your insurance or return your plates until the title has transferred out of your name.
- If you sold privately, verify the buyer's payment has cleared before considering the transaction final.
- Keep all paperwork (bill of sale, payoff confirmation, title receipt) for at least one year.
Full Disclosure: How Vantage Fits In
Vantage is a licensed auto broker in New Jersey. We handle step 3 (getting competing offers) for you, and we help coordinate step 5 (completing the transaction) smoothly. We represent sellers, not buyers. Depending on the deal structure, Vantage may earn a broker fee, disclosed upfront. If you are also shopping for your next vehicle, you can browse our wholesale inventory while your trade is being processed.
To start the process, start your trade in 5 minutes. No spam. No pressure. Unsubscribe anytime.
