Why Carvana's APR Is Higher Than You Expected
You found the car you want on Carvana. The price looked fair. Then you got to the financing screen, and the APR made you do a double take. 11.9%. Maybe 14.5%. Maybe higher.
You are not imagining it. Carvana's interest rates are consistently higher than what you would get from a bank, credit union, or even most traditional dealerships. And there is a straightforward reason for it: financing markup is one of the primary ways Carvana makes money.
How Carvana's Financing Actually Works
Carvana is not a bank. They partner with lending institutions that provide the capital for your loan. Here is the simplified version of what happens:
- A lending partner approves you at a base rate (say 7%)
- Carvana adds a markup (sometimes 3-6 points or more)
- You see the final rate (10-13%) on the checkout screen
- Carvana keeps the spread as revenue
This is not unique to Carvana. Traditional dealerships do the same thing with their finance departments. The difference is that Carvana's entire model depends on this revenue stream. Their SEC filings show that finance and insurance products are a meaningful portion of their gross profit per unit.
The convenience of buying online comes at a cost, and that cost is often baked into the APR rather than the sticker price.
What Rate Should You Actually Be Getting?
As of early 2026, here is a rough benchmark for used-car loan rates based on credit tier:
- Excellent (750+): 5.5-7.5% through a credit union
- Good (700-749): 7.0-9.5% through a bank or credit union
- Fair (650-699): 9.5-13.0% through a bank
- Below 650: 13.0-18.0%+ (rates vary significantly)
Now compare those to what Carvana buyers commonly report: even buyers with scores above 720 frequently see rates of 10-14% through Carvana's platform. That gap represents the markup, and it can cost you thousands over a 60 or 72-month loan.
On a $30,000 car financed over 60 months, the difference between 7% and 12% is roughly $4,200 in additional interest. That is real money.
Why Carvana Can Charge More (And Gets Away With It)
Three factors work in Carvana's favor:
1. Convenience Bias
Carvana's whole value proposition is speed and ease. Buyers who are drawn to the "buy from your couch" experience often accept the financing terms without shopping around. The platform is designed to move you through checkout quickly, and rate comparison is not part of that flow.
2. Bundled Experience
When financing is integrated into the purchase, it feels like a package deal. Separating the car purchase from the financing decision takes extra effort, and Carvana benefits from buyers who do not take that step.
3. Limited Negotiation
Unlike a traditional dealer where you might push back on the rate, Carvana's platform does not allow negotiation. The rate you see is the rate you get. This removes friction for Carvana but removes leverage for you.
How to Lower Your Rate When Buying From Carvana
The good news: you have several options to avoid paying Carvana's markup.
Option 1: Get Pre-Approved Before You Shop
Visit your bank or credit union before you start browsing Carvana. Get a pre-approval letter with your rate and terms. This gives you a baseline. If Carvana's rate is higher (it almost certainly will be), you can use your own lender's financing instead.
Most credit unions offer competitive used-car rates, especially if you have a checking account or direct deposit relationship with them.
Option 2: Use Carvana's Financing, Then Refinance
If you want to close the deal quickly and sort out financing later, you can accept Carvana's rate and refinance within 60-90 days. There is typically no prepayment penalty on Carvana loans. A refinance through a credit union can drop your rate by 3-6 points.
This approach works, but it requires discipline. Many buyers intend to refinance and never get around to it. Set a calendar reminder for 60 days after purchase.
Option 3: Skip Carvana's Financing Entirely
Carvana accepts third-party financing. You can arrange your own loan through a bank, credit union, or online lender, and provide that information during checkout. Carvana will coordinate with your lender to complete the transaction.
Option 4: Consider a Broker Instead
A broker like Vantage does not mark up financing. We help you find the car at the best price and connect you with competitive lending options. Our broker fee is disclosed upfront, and there is no hidden interest rate markup padding the deal.
The Real Cost of Not Shopping Your Rate
Here is a quick comparison on a $35,000 used car, 60-month term:
- Credit union at 6.5%: $685/month, $6,100 total interest
- Carvana at 12.5%: $790/month, $12,400 total interest
- Difference: $105/month, $6,300 over the life of the loan
That $6,300 could cover a year of insurance, a vacation, or a significant chunk of your next car's down payment. All for 30 minutes of rate shopping.
What Vantage Does Differently
We do not operate a finance desk that profits from rate markup. When we help you find a car, the financing is separate and transparent. We will point you toward competitive lenders, explain the terms, and disclose our broker fee so you know exactly what you are paying and to whom.
That said, we are not a bank either. You will still want to compare the rates we connect you with against your own bank or credit union. Transparency means giving you the information to make the best decision, not just funneling you into a single option.
Get your free quote in under 5 minutes and see what your car should actually cost, with transparent financing. No spam. No pressure. Unsubscribe anytime.
.avif)
